Green Horizons

Volume 3, Number 2
Spring 1998

MNGA Nut Show analysis

Missouri Nut Growers gathered at Nevada, Mo. in early February to crack hundreds of nuts to determine the best of the 1997 crop. The judges were looking for high kernel percentage and size as well as high quality. The following listing shows the results including a notation of number of nuts per pound.

Seedling pecans and walnuts are those trees that have grown from a native nut with unknown parentage or grown from a nut from a tree that was grafted to a known cultivar (mother tree) but the male parent is unknown.

Cultivars are nuts from trees that have been grafted to known, recognized cultivars or varieties. These grafted trees essentially are clones. However, sites, weather conditions and cultural practices result in differences in nuts. The same cultivar grown by three different producers at different sites around the state may vary by three or more points in percentage of kernel. This can often be seen when comparing nuts from a plantation that has been fertilized and irrigated to those from a plantation that has not received such care.

It should be noted that many "seedling" nuts have been named but are not recognized by the Missouri Nut Growers Association as a true cultivar. Cultivar status usually is achieved when the seedling is accepted by a large number of growers and is deemed to have commercial or specific breeding value.

This year's show had the most black walnut entries on record and the pecan entries were the highest in several years. It should be noted that many of the seedlings, especially in the black walnut class, have very low kernel percentages. Most of these entries are natives that have not been analyzed before. The parent tree may have shown the sought after qualities of high nut production and a trend toward annual bearing, but the nuts themselves yield small amounts of kernel or are of poor kernel quality. All these elements must come together to be recognized as a top cultivar.

In the pecan seedling category, there were several new "finds" that came from native groves, city parks and individual trees in pastures. Most notable is the pecan entered by Mary Ann Byrd of Butler, Mo. This seedling not only has a fairly high kernel percentage, but also is fairly large (only 80 nuts per pound). In contrast, the other top- placing seedling pecans all were rather small nuts requiring more than 100 nuts to make a pound.

One of the show judges, Bill Reid, director of the Pecan Experiment Field at Chetopa, Kansas, reported that several exceptionally large seedling pecan nuts showed up in this year's show. Most of these are coming from the southern part of the state. He feels that many of these are coming from trees that have grown from nuts produced by grafted trees that were introduced into Missouri at the beginning of this cen tury. The grafted stock came from southern nurseries and were some of the older, well-known southern cultivars such as Stuart. The seedling trees often produce large nuts typical of the southern varieties. The trees may also be cold hardy enough to survive in Missouri, especially in the southern portion. However, the nuts may not mature because of Missouri's shorter growing season.

In the black walnut seedling class, the first place winner is a recent find from south Missouri. Its 31.58 percent kernel makes it worth watching for other desirable characteristics. Most of the seedling walnuts, though, had little to offer in kernel percentage since the average of native nuts is about 20 percent.

Special awards were given to Paul Woody, Bronaugh, Mo. for the Grand Champion black walnut cultivar (Surprise); Bill Reid, Chetopa, Kan. for the Grand Champion pecan cultivar (Kanza); Bob Nieman, Lockwood, Mo. for 1st Place black walnut seedling and Mary Ann Byrd, Butler, Mo. for 1st Place pecan seedling.


Bill Reid, left, presents Grand Champion black walnut
cultivar award to Paul Woody for his "Suprise."


Phil Rotert, MNGA president, right, presents Grand
Champion pecan cultivar award to Bill Reid for his "Kanza."


Mary Ann Byrd, right, receives award for 1st Place pecan seedling.
Seedling pecans
                                  %       Nuts 
Grower        Tree              Kernel    /Lb.   Place
=======================================================
M. Byrd       Seedling #2        49.38    80.00   1st
P. Rotert     #12                48.50   100.00   2nd
J. Rupp       Jenkins            52.91   114.28   3rd
B. Kussman    Irma               47.87   114.28   4th
L. Weber      #1                 45.07    88.89
P. Woody      #1                 52.91   100.00
R. Dye        #108               43.11    88.89
N. Schafer    #202               42.33    80.00
N. Schafer    #299               45.56    66.67
B. Nieman     #3                 43.11    88.89
P. Rotert     #38                43.11    88.89
P. Rotert     #64                37.79   114.28
P. Rotert     #7                 43.29    72.73
J. Stewart    #780               39.68   100.00
G. Kempf      12K67              41.89   100.00
D. Warren     317                49.97   133.33
D. Warren     346                42.83   114.28
J. Wilson     B12                35.27    72.73
J. Wilson     B2                 35.27   114.28
J. Wilson     Bee Tree           41.15    88.89
G. Nuse       Brohn              49.97   133.33
J. Byram      Delane             41.89   100.00
G. Kempf      F                  35.27   133.33
B. Nieman     Fence Row          48.10    72.73
B. Kussman    Goose Pond         43.29    72.73
D. Grotjan    Grotjan #1         47.03    88.89
W. Adams      Harts              45.86    53.33
L. Harper     HH-P1              35.27   133.33
V. Byrd       Improved Seedling  44.68    53.33
J. Byram      Kelly              42.83   114.28
B. Kussman    Kussman            49.97   133.33
W. Adams      Marylou            49.80    47.06
P. Woody      McDowell 16        49.38    80.00
N. Wilkerson  N1                 44.89    72.73
N. Wilkerson  N2                 38.80    80.00
D. Johnson    Native 15          48.99    88.89
G. Gardner    Ozarkia            41.15   133.33
G. McDowell   Pond               40.08    72.73
D. Warren     Rema               45.86    80.00
G. Nuse       Sandy              41.89   100.00
M. Byrd       Seedling #1        37.79   114.28
J. Bays       Seedling #1        40.56    80.00
J. Rupp       Sturgis            42.62    66.67
G. McDowell   Top Middle Tree    46.13    61.54
G. McDowell   Top Row            39.68    66.67
G. McDowell   Unknown            51.55    61.54
J. Wilson     unnamed            42.33    80.00
J. Rupp       Walker             42.83   114.28
G. Gardner    Warren             57.32   100.00
P. Woody      Woody #1           58.79   133.33


Pecan cultivars
Grower       Tree                % Kernel  Nuts/Lb. Place
==========================================================
B. Kussman   Colby                 43.20    61.54   1st
R. Dye       Colby                 39.68   100.00
R. Dye       Colby                 42.33    80.00
             
G. Gardner   Dooley                47.03    88.89   1st
W. Knaust    Dooley                48.10    72.73
B. Nieman    Dooley                45.86    80.00
P. Woody     Dooley                45.35   114.28
             
R. Dye       Giles                 54.87    88.89   1st
P. Woody     Giles                 51.15    80.00
V. Byrd      Giles                 43.41    61.54
R. Dye       Giles                 57.32   100.00
R. Dye       Giles                 50.95    88.89
G. Gardner   Giles                 54.51    72.73
             
G. McDowell  Mohawk                59.41    42.10   1st
J. Wilson    Mohawk                58.10    47.06
G. Gardner   Mohawk                57.32    50.00
             
G. McDowell  Pawnee                56.02    47.06   1st
V. Byrd      Pawnee                58.79    44.44
G. Kempf     Pawnee                40.31    57.14
             
P. Woody     Peruque               62.71    88.89   1st
E. Williams  Peruque               59.52    100.00
R. Dye       Peruque               47.03    88.89
K. Hunt      Peruque               66.63    88.89
             
G. Kempf     Posey                 57.72    72.73   1st
R. Dye       Posey                 54.51    72.73
R. Dye       Posey                 56.44    80.00
K. Hunt      Posey                 60.93    72.73
D. Warren    Posey                 55.85    66.67
             
W. Reid      Kanza                 54.51    72.73   1st
B. Kussman   Niblack               49.38    80.00   2nd
W. Reid      Canton                49.38    80.00
J. Wilson    Chief                 46.30    50.00
J. Wilson    GraCross              55.85    66.67
P. Woody     Greenriver            54.27    61.54
J. Wilson    Greenriver            52.91    66.67
P. Woody     Hirschi               48.50   100.00
J. Stewart   Hirschi               48.50   100.00
P. Woody     Indiana               49.38    80.00
P. Woody     Johnson               38.80    80.00
D. Warren    Lucas                 58.79   133.33
P. Woody     Major                 47.03    88.89
M. Koehn     Major                 51.31    72.73
J. Wilson    Maramec               52.91    66.67
G. McDowell  Maramec               52.91    57.14
G. McDowell  McLaurie              45.56    66.67
G. McDowell  McLeon                48.84    61.54
W. Reid      Norton                49.97    66.67
D. Warren    Norton                43.41    61.54
G. Gardner   Osage                 51.31    72.73
P. Woody     S. Hirschi            47.62    80.00
P. Woody     Shephard              48.50   100.00
G. Gardner   Shephard              48.10    72.73
J. Wilson    Shoshoni              54.27    61.54
R. Dye       Starking Hardy Giant  44.09   100.00
J. Stewart   Stuart                50.39    57.14
P. Woody     Unknown               50.95    88.89
G. McDowell  USDA 61-4-36          62.67    53.33
E. Williams  Witte                 54.51    72.73


Seedling black walnuts      
                                 %      Nuts
Grower       Tree              Kernel   /Lb.   Place
 ====================================================
B. Nieman    Pond Tree          31.58   29.84   1st
B. Lane      Lee's Summit       23.08   17.45   2nd
G. Gardner   Gardner 345        22.86   32.40   3rd
J. Fann      #1                 16.67   21.00
G. Messner   #11                21.62   30.65
J. Fann      #2                 11.11   25.20
J. Devine    Agnes Blomes       21.43   20.25
L. Harper    Briscoe #1         12.24   23.14
L. Harper    Briscoe #2         20.00   28.35
L. Harper    Briscoe #3         19.15   24.13
L. Harper    Briscoe #4         19.35   36.58
J. Devine    Devine #1          25.41   18.59
P. Moore     Drain Tree         24.24   34.36
J. Fleck     FBW-1              10.00   32.40
J. Devine    Gray Summit        14.15   21.40
J. Devine    Hanlon #8          23.53   33.35
K. Hunt      HR3                24.07   21.00
J. Devine    Long Walnut        29.76   27.00
G. Gardner   Ozark King         25.00   21.81
G. McDowell  Tank Tree          26.25   28.35
P. Moore     Williams Seedling  25.00   47.25
P. Woody     Woody #1           23.96   23.62
P. Woody     Woody #2           22.60   15.53
N. Workman   Workman #1         19.15   24.13

Black walnut cultivars
                                  %      Nuts 
Grower       Cultivar           Kernel   /Lb.   Place
======================================================
K. Hunt      Clermont            23.68   19.89   1st
P. Moore     Clermont            21.82   20.62
B. Lane      Clermont            25.00   19.55

J. Stevens   Emma-K              28.75   28.35   1st
W. Knaust    Emma-K              33.67   23.14   2nd
E. Williams  Emma-K              30.00   25.20
K. Hunt      Emma-K              30.00   28.35
G. Gardner   Emma-K              34.78   24.65
B. Lane      Emma-K              30.85   24.13
G. Leaming   Emma-K              30.68   25.77

W. Knaust    Football            29.46   20.25   1st
J. Stevens   Football            19.77   26.37   2nd
P. Woody     Football            21.82   20.62
P. Moore     Football            24.24   34.36
K. Hunt      Football            24.07   21.00
G. Leaming   Football            22.73   25.77
G. Gardner   Football            26.00   22.68

B. Lane      Kwik-Krop           27.27   25.77   1st
E. Williams  Kwik-Krop           26.83   27.66   2nd
P. Moore     Kwik-Krop           22.37   29.84
J. Stevens   Kwik-Krop           25.53   24.13
W. Knaust    Kwik-Krop           29.46   20.25
G. Gardner   Kwik-Krop           28.00   22.68
B. Lane      Mintle              26.56   35.44   1st
E. Williams  Mintle (B. Nugget)  24.29   32.40   2nd
P. Woody     Mintle (B. Nugget)  25.00   31.50
J. Stevens   Mintle (B. Nugget)  20.59   33.35
B. Lane      Mintle (B. Nugget)  25.71   32.40
K. Hunt      Mintle (B. Nugget)  22.22   31.50

P. Woody     Sauber              25.61   27.66   1st
J. Stevens   Sauber              27.27   34.36
E. Williams  Sauber              29.46   20.25
G. Gardner   Sauber              30.30   34.36
B. Lane      Sauber              31.25   28.35

E. Williams  Sparks 127          34.21   29.84   1st
B. Lane      Sparks 127          29.73   30.65
G. Gardner   Sparks 127          30.56   31.50
B. Lane      Sparks 147          35.14   30.65

E. Williams  Sparrow             28.21   29.08   1st
W. Knaust    Sparrow             26.85   21.00   2nd
P. Moore     Sparrow             26.74   26.37
J. Stevens   Sparrow             26.67   25.20
L. Harper    Sparrow             27.55   23.14
G. Gardner   Sparrow             25.56   25.20

P. Woody     Surprise            29.63   21.00   1st
B. Lane      Surprise            30.85   24.13   2nd
E. Williams  Surprise            27.91   26.37
G. Gardner   Surprise            29.09   20.62
K. Hunt      Surprise            22.45   23.14
W. Knaust    Surprise            32.41   21.00
G. Leaming   Surprise            27.55   23.14

B. Lane      Tomboy              24.00   22.68   1st
E. Williams  Tomboy              22.12   21.81   2nd
P. Moore     Tomboy              20.65   24.65
G. Gardner   Tomboy              23.00   22.68

W. Knaust    Bowser              29.76   27.00   1st
B. Lane      Hare                26.67   18.90   2nd
G. Gardner   Hay II              27.63   29.84   3rd
G. Gardner   Jackson             31.25   35.44   4th
G. Gardner   Bowser              24.36   29.08
B. Lane      Crosby              22.64   21.40
B. Lane      Daniels             30.65   18.29
B. Lane      Dubois              27.78   25.20
E. Williams  Harney              25.56   25.20
E. Williams  Hay                 30.16   18.00
B. Lane      Hay                 30.36   20.25
E. Williams  HRC3                25.93   21.00
E. Williams  Jackson             24.53   42.79
G. Gardner   Mystery             23.26   26.37
B. Lane      Mystery             25.51   23.14
B. Lane      Ogden               22.64   21.40
E. Williams  Patterson           29.76   27.00
B. Lane      Patterson           32.56   26.37
E. Williams  Ridgeway            22.56   13.83
G. Gardner   Ridgeway            20.37   14.00
B. Lane      Rowher              27.36   21.40
G. Gardner   Rowher              21.67   18.90
E. Williams  Sauber II           26.47   33.35
B. Lane      Schreiber           26.56   17.72
G. Gardner   Shessler            26.60   24.13
E. Williams  South Fork          20.69   39.10
B. Lane      Stanek              19.23   21.81
J. Stevens   Thomas              23.15   21.00
B. Lane      Thomas              25.41   18.59
E. Williams  Thomas-Myers        30.56   21.00
G. Gardner   Thomas-Myers        27.68   20.25
E. Williams  Woody               22.22   36.00

Hickories
                                       %      Nuts   
Grower       Species    Cultivar     Kernel   /Lb.   Place
==========================================================
E. Williams  Mockernut  Windsor Park  18.75   47.25
E. Williams  Shagbark   Wilcox        36.67   75.60

J. Stewart   Shellbark  959           29.17   18.90   1st
J. Stewart   Shellbark  873           29.17   23.62   2nd
J. Stewart   Shellbark  867           27.78   31.50
J. Stewart   Shellbark  872           21.15   21.81
J. Stewart   Shellbark  874           31.25   23.62
J. Stewart   Shellbark  875           22.22   21.00
J. Stewart   Shellbark  Banana        23.33   18.90
J. Wilson    Shellbark  JW1           15.31   23.14


Miscellaneous nut species
                                          %      Nuts   
Grower       Species    Cultivar        Kernel   /Lb.   Place
=============================================================
K. Hunt      Chestnut   Sleeping Giant  22.68           1st
K. Hunt      Chestnut   AU-Cropper      54.00
K. Hunt      Chestnut   AU-Homestead    22.23
K. Hunt      Chestnut   Crane           29.84
K. Hunt      Chestnut   Mossbarger      29.08
K. Hunt      Chestnut   Revival         25.20

K. Hunt      Heartnut   Canoka          21.05   59.68

J. Wilson    Hican      Wilson          43.86   39.79   1st
P. Woody     Hican      Weese           41.67   37.80   2nd
D. Warren    Hican      Gun Club        26.67   50.40
B. Lane      Hican      Underwood       30.30   34.36